Live Edison phonography at the Catalyst Club, Brighton, 10 December 09

Edison phonograph advertisement (source: Library of Congress)

Edison phonograph advertisement (source: Library of Congress)

I’ll be getting out the camel hair brush and putting my 1904 Edison Standard Phonograph through its paces at the Catalyst Club, Brighton, 10 December 2009. Hear some commercial wax cylinders from the early 1900s and witness a live recording of a voice from the audience, straight onto a blank cylinder of carnauba wax.

I’ll also be talking a little about Edison’s life and his interest in the supernatural – particularly his thoughts on capturing the voices of the dead.

Hosted by Dr David Bramwell, the Catalyst Club is a monthly Brighton event that pays tribute to the old traditions of French Salon, debating societies and Gentleman’s Clubs.

Don’t read before dinner: how to fake the sound of…

…vomit.

red bucketIt’s an awkward position to be in: you need the sound of vomit but don’t have any of it handy. This is the problem I was facing in 2003, when I created a small exhibit for the Museum of Science and Industry, Manchester.

It all started when I was approached by acoustician Trevor Cox to make an exhibit about unpleasant sounds: fingers down the blackboard, babies crying, ringtones, the sound of someone slurping their dinner and other ghastly delights. I persuaded Trevor to turn the exhibit some kind of test – a booth where visitors could test their endurance of the ‘worst sounds in the world’. A simple idea – but one that hit the buffers when I started hunting around for library sound effects – the kind you can buy in packs of 200 on CD. I don’t know who library tracks are made for but I have to say they don’t cut the mustard if you’re looking for something that genuinely puts your teeth on edge. So I decided to spend a couple of days, in the company of some actors, making my own recordings. Here are the details for making one of those sounds – simulated vomit (please don’t venture any further if it’s teatime):

The sound of vomit – here’s one I prepared earlier

How to fake the sound of vomiting

beansYou will need

1 tin of baked beans (any make will do)

1/2 litre of tepid water

A plastic bucket

A mug

An actor with a sterling constitution

A sound recording and editing system with reverb

Instructions

1) Pour the beans into the bowl and mix in the water to make a sloppy broth.

2) Scoop out a mug full of the broth.

3) Holding your mic just inside the bowl, empty your mug into the bowl, while you record the sound. Make sure you record every part of the action – including the moment when the mixture first hits the bowl.

4) Repeat step 3 several times. Experiment with different amounts of broth. Also experiment with slow and fast emptying of the mug. Try and get some recordings where the broth hits the bare plastic of the bowl, others where it hits the broth that’s already in there. This extra effort will pay dividends later.

5) Ask your actor to make some retching sounds, as though he is about to be sick. If you are working with a method actor, you may find it helpful to let him smell or touch the broth at this juncture. Record the sounds he makes. It’s especially good if he can imitate the sound of a small piece of onion being stuck in the throat.

6) Now you have your raw materials, it’s time to edit them together to make a convincing vomiting sound. Listen to the recordings you have made and cut and paste the best takes to make a sequence of alternating retches and broth falls. You may like to start with some more delicate sounds that build towards a climax. Make sure you leave a hiatus between each retch and broth fall. And remember, you’re simulating a natural function here so don’t bee too metronomic about the placing of the sounds (unless you’re trying to beat match this to some music). Vary the pattern as much as you like – be creative!

The reverb plugin in Logic

The reverb plugin in Logic

7) Your sound effect is almost complete but a little reverberation will help to stitch the two elements of your sound together, convincing the listener that the two are taking place in the same space. A reverb of around 3.5 seconds should be ample for a domestic toilet but feel free to experiment here. The larger your imaginary room is and the more tiled its surfaces are, the longer the reverb will be. Most reverbs have a knob that lets you adjust the amount of ‘wet’ and ‘dry’ sound. Here, ‘wet’ sound is the sound that has been given the reverb treatment, ‘dry’ sound is your original sound. Start with a wet-to-dry ratio of around 30% but increase this if you want to give the impression your actor is further away. You may find you can increase the perception of distance by cutting the high frequencies a little.

Some related sites

Bad Vibes project website (sponsored at the EPSRC)

Interview with Monique Reymond, Foley Artist

Foley artists use umbrellas, dog food and a host of other unlikely items to make the incidental sounds in movies.

The Reverb Jam: extemporising in extreme reverb

Introduction (with videos)

Sound clips (including R4 Today Programme interview)

Baffles on the ceiling of the National Physical Laboratory reverb chamber

Baffles on the ceiling of the National Physical Laboratory reverb chamber

The line-up

Oddities of working in a reverberant space

Relaxing in the semi-anechoic chamber

Why make reverb chambers?

Be My Baby (reverb and the Wall of Sound)

The project

In December 2006, Spacedog assembled a group of musicians in the reverb chamber of the UK National Physical Laboratory. This room has one of the longest reverberation times in Europe.

These videos show you what happened – you can read more about the project on these page. NB In these videos, the people you see on camera are the only musicians playing – no sounds have been added after the event (except during the purple intro sequence). The extra sound you’re hearing is the long tail of reverb that follows each note, as sound bounces for up to 30 seconds around this highly reflective room. You hear this tail, before you hear notes, on videos that are playing backwards.

A primer on reverbation

Reverberation or ‘reverb’ is what you hear when sound bounces off the walls, floor and other surfaces of a room, creating a mush of echoes that slowly die away. Acousticians judge how long sound bounces around the room by measuring the ‘reverberation time of the space’. Technically, this is how long it takes for the sound to decay by 60dB. The easiest way to make a rough judgement of the reverb in the room is to pop a balloon in there, or clap your hands. If the sudden impulse of noise – the pop or clap – dies away almost instantly, your room has a very short reverb. If it rings for some time afterwards, you have a long reverb.

If you’re sitting in a small, carpeted room right now, it’s likely that your reverb time will only be around 0.5 secs. That’s scarcely enough for you to notice the sound that continues after you stop speaking. A hall that has been tailor-made for orchestral concerts might have a reverb time of around 2 to 3 seconds. A large, tiled bathroom might have a reverb of 5 secs or so. St Paul’s Cathedral has a reverb time of up to 13 seconds for bass notes.

The reverberation chamber of the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) outstrips all of these. Low bass notes (around 100Hz – roughly the pitch you get on the bass string of a ‘cello) reverberate for over 30 seconds. This long reverb is no surprise when you see how the room is constructed: The room is an empty chamber with concrete floors, ceiling and walls to keep the sound bouncing around. Extra plastic panels are hung from the ceiling to add more reflective surfaces. And the walls are non-parallel so echoes bounce in all directions (this prevents the build-up of standing waves).

National Physical Laboratory

On a visit to NPL in early 2006, I met acoustic scientist Dr Richard Lord who showed me the company’s new reverb chamber. He popped a balloon in there to show off its amazing reverb. As soon as I heard this, I knew I wanted to take some of musical instruments in there. I play various musical oddities, including a waterphone and musical saw, and I thought my sounds might find a home in this strange acoustic. NPL agreed I could come along, with some other musicians, on a day when the chamber was empty.

Recording a take in the reverb chamber of the National Physical Laboratory. The longest notes on Stephen's 'cello reverberate for over 30 seconds when the room is almost empty.

Recording a take in the reverb chamber of the National Physical Laboratory. The longest notes on Stephen's 'cello reverberate for over 30 seconds when the room is almost empty.

<INTRO (WITH VIDEOS) | SOUNDS | NEXT>